Africa needs scientists at the negotiating table

Africa needs scientists at the negotiating table

Connecting scientists with diplomats can help African governments negotiate complex agreements on health, technology, climate and natural resources.

Imagine a government negotiating an international research agreement involving genomic data collected from people in its country. Before agreeing, it needs to understand who can access those data, where they will be analysed, how participants will be protected and what local researchers and institutions might gain. Without that understanding, important safeguards or benefits could be overlooked. Similar technical questions arise in negotiations on pandemic preparedness, artificial intelligence, climate change and critical minerals.

Science diplomacy connects scientific expertise to foreign policy and international cooperation. For African governments, a practical priority is to ensure that negotiators have systematic access to scientific and technical advice. The aim is not to replace diplomats with scientists, but to ensure that governments can draw on relevant expertise when making decisions. Governments remain responsible for defining national interests and negotiating on behalf of their citizens. Scientific expertise strengthens that process by helping negotiators understand what is technically possible, identify trade-offs, test assumptions and assess the longer-term implications of proposed agreements.

A practical priority is to ensure that negotiators have systematic access to scientific and technical advice

The African Union has already recognised this need. Its Science, Technology and Innovation Strategy for Africa 2034 identifies science diplomacy as an important enabler of the continent’s science and innovation ambitions. The practical question is: how can African countries organise that support nationally and draw on regional and continental expertise where needed?

The negotiations around the WHO Pandemic Agreement show why this matters. COVID-19 demonstrated that access to scientific information, manufacturing capability, diagnostics, vaccines and therapeutics can quickly become questions of diplomacy, equity and national interest. During the negotiations, African health ministers worked to articulate shared priorities, including equitable access to medical products, technology transfer and stronger regional production. Africa CDC provided political, strategic and technical support to national negotiators rather than negotiating on behalf of countries.

That distinction is important. Continental institutions can help countries pool expertise, identify areas of common interest and approach negotiations with greater coherence. At the same time, individual states retain their diplomatic responsibilities and implement agreements through their own laws and regulatory systems. The World Health Assembly adopted the Pandemic Agreement in May 2025, while negotiations on its Pathogen Access and Benefit Sharing (PABS) annex continued during 2026. The proposed system aims to enable the rapid sharing of pathogens with pandemic potential and their genetic sequence information, while ensuring fair access to benefits such as vaccines, diagnostic tests and treatments. The challenge is agreeing on how these arrangements would work in practice, including how benefits would be shared when medical products are in short supply.

The issues are highly technical. Negotiators need to understand laboratory networks, genomic sequence information, surveillance systems, manufacturing capacity, intellectual property and public health needs. Such expertise helps governments assess whether proposed commitments are workable and what they imply for production capacity, access to medical products and national priorities.

Human genomics raises a different but related set of questions. Who can access genomic data, and where will they be stored and analysed? Under what conditions can samples or data cross borders? How are participants’ consent and privacy protected? And who benefits from discoveries made using these resources? Answering these questions requires scientific expertise alongside legal and ethical judgement.

Although the Human Heredity and Health in Africa (H3Africa) initiative is not a diplomatic negotiating body, it offers a useful example of how international research collaborations can be governed. Its Data and Biospecimen Access Committee reviews requests to use genomic data and biological samples, including whether the proposed use is consistent with participants’ consent and access requirements. This allows scientific collaboration to continue while access remains subject to agreed safeguards.

This is where data sovereignty becomes important. It does not mean keeping African genomic data out of international research. Rather, it means having the scientific, legal and institutional capacity to make informed decisions about how data are shared, with whom, under what conditions and for whose benefit, while respecting the rights of research participants.

Climate diplomacy perhaps provides the clearest example of scientific expertise being directly connected to negotiating capacity. The African Group of Negotiators Experts Support (AGNES) was established to provide evidence-based technical support to African governments and the African Group of Negotiators in international climate processes. Its work includes synthesising scientific evidence, helping negotiators prepare common African positions and supporting technical engagement ahead of climate conferences.

At COP23 in 2017, AGNES provided technical support to African negotiators working on agriculture and gender. Its contribution helped inform negotiations that led to the adoption of the Koronivia Joint Work on Agriculture, which established a formal process under the UN climate convention to address agriculture and climate change.

Climate negotiators need to interpret emissions pathways, adaptation metrics, climate finance methodologies and agricultural impacts. A standing interface between experts and negotiators allows evidence to inform positions before and during negotiations rather than being added after political positions have already been fixed. The same principle can apply in other technically complex areas, including artificial intelligence, biotechnology and critical minerals.

Governments can begin by connecting expertise in universities, research institutes, regulatory agencies and national academies more systematically to foreign policy. One obstacle may be the lack of regular channels through which ministries can identify and involve relevant experts before negotiating positions are developed. Foreign affairs ministries could maintain networks of scientific and technical advisers who can be mobilised for particular negotiations. Scientists could undertake short secondments in ministries and diplomatic missions, while diplomats could receive greater exposure to emerging scientific and technological issues. Countries with sufficient capacity could also consider science and innovation advisers or attachés in selected missions.

Regional and continental institutions have an important complementary role. The African Union, Africa CDC and specialised networks can convene expertise, support shared principles and help countries access highly specialised knowledge that may not be available domestically. African countries have different laws, regulatory systems, research capacities and national priorities. Continental principles can support common expectations and cross-border cooperation, but implementation must remain responsive to national contexts. For some issues, common African positions can increase coherence and negotiating weight. The goal should not be uniformity across African countries, but rather stronger capabilities at both the national and continental levels.

Continental principles can support common expectations and cross-border cooperation, but implementation must remain responsive to national contexts

Scientific advice also needs to arrive early. Bringing experts into the process only after negotiation positions have been agreed limits their contribution. Scientists, engineers, lawyers, economists and other specialists should help governments understand emerging issues, identify possible consequences and clarify options ahead of formal processes. This does not diminish political authority, yet allows political choices to be made with a fuller understanding of what is at stake.

A country may have a seat at the negotiating table and still struggle to understand the implications of what it is agreeing to. Stronger diplomacy therefore requires more than representation. Governments need timely access to experts who can explain the science, identify the trade-offs and help them make informed choices. That expertise should be part of preparing for negotiations, not something governments seek only after decisions have been made.

 

Image: geralt/Pixabay

Republication of our Africa Tomorrow articles only with permission. Contact us for any enquiries.


Chat to our site